Planning · Estimate guide

How to compare roofing estimates

Questions to ask when comparing roofing proposals, including work scope, materials, cleanup, changes and warranty paperwork.

Put the proposals on the same page

Before comparing totals, write down what each proposal actually includes. Use the questions below as a discussion worksheet. An unanswered question is a reason to request clarification before deciding.

  • Which roof areas and components are included?
  • Is the proposal for a repair, replacement or another defined scope?
  • What materials and product names are specified?
  • What work is excluded from the quoted amount?

Ask how changes are handled

Ask the contractor to explain what happens if additional work is identified. Request a clear process for documenting the finding, pricing the change and obtaining your agreement. Ask who your point of contact will be during the job.

  • How will additional work be photographed and explained?
  • How will a revised price be provided?
  • Who authorizes changes, and how is that agreement recorded?

Discuss the property as well as the roof

A proposal conversation is also the time to discuss access, parking, pets, landscaping and cleanup. Tell the contractor about anything that needs special attention. Ask how weather may affect the schedule and how you will receive updates.

  • Where will materials and waste containers be placed?
  • What do you need to move before the crew arrives?
  • How are debris removal and the final walkthrough handled?

Keep the documents you will need later

Ask for the written scope, payment schedule and applicable warranty documents before agreeing to the work. Keep the final invoice, approved changes and product information together. If insurance is involved, also ask your insurer to explain your coverage and out-of-pocket responsibility; roof coverage may be based on replacement cost or actual cash value.

  • What does the contractor’s workmanship warranty cover?
  • Which manufacturer documents apply to the selected products?
  • Who should you contact if a concern arises after completion?

Sources and further reading

Texas Department of Insurance: Insurance and your roof ↗

General educational information. Your roof, written contract and insurance policy determine the details that apply to your situation.

Start with a free inspection

Have a question about your own roof?

Share what you have noticed. Russ and the team can explain how an inspection can help.

Call Russ940.395.9413
This prepares an email in your preferred mail app. Prefer to write directly? russ@russroofing.com.
Call RussFree Inspection